NAIC #
Company Name
Premium
Number
Index
1
33898
Aegis Security Insurance Company
728,542
1
DNC
2
19240
Allstate Indemnity Company
2,498,961
2
19.71
3
19232
Allstate Insurance Company
45,755,099
4
2.15
4
17230
Allstate Property And Casualty Insurance Company
58,431,436
5
2.11
5
19275
American Family Mutual Insurance Company
81,690,022
4
1.21
6
38652
American Modern Select Insurance Company
5,188,327
1
4.75
7
19992
American Select Insurance Company
6,245,114
1
3.94
8
10052
Chubb National Insurance Company
7,680,181
1
3.21
9
29734
Conifer Insurance Company
4,560,272
1
5.40
10
40649
Economy Premier Assurance Company
1,393,820
1
17.67
11
22292
Hanover Insurance Company
1,171
1
DNC
12
13927
Homesite Insurance Company of the Midwest
18,528,214
2
2.66
13
22624
Indiana Farmers Mutual Insurance Company
45,541,821
1
0.54
14
42404
Liberty Insurance Corporation
11,949,914
1
2.06
15
33600
LM Insurance Corporation
11,019,915
1
2.23
16
23043
Liberty Mutual Insurance Company
None
1
DNC
17
21229
MemberSelect Insurance Company
10,050,059
1
2.45
18
23353
Meridian Security Insurance Company
13,528,349
1
1.82
19
14621
Motorists Mutual Insurance Company
6,307,467
1
3.90
20
23779
Nationwide Mutual Fire Insurance Company
18,676,418
1
1.32
21
32700
Owners Insurance Company
26,433,189
3
2.80
22
32905
Property-Owners Insurance Company
23,933,789
1
1.03
23
11000
Sentinel Insurance Company, Ltd.
1,625,531
1
15.15
24
25143
State Farm Fire and Casualty Company
484,909,595
27
1.37
25
25178
State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company
None
1
DNC
26
40118
Trustgard Insurance Company
11,905,377
2
4.14
27
15288
United Farm Family Mutual Insurance Company
137,742,927
4
0.72
28
44393
West American Insurance Company
(35,270)
1
DNC
Subtotal Premium and Complaints
1,036,290,240
72
162 Companies with Zero Complaints
737,032,294
Total Premium and Complaints
1,773,322,534
72
Report does not include 162 companies with zero complaints
DNC- did not calculate (premiums under $1 million)
None – No premium was reported during 2014.
Premium information from Property & Casualty Annual Statement Page 19, Line 4, Column 1